Sherwin Williams vs. Benjamin Moore Paint: An Expert Comparison

When it comes to selecting high-quality paint for your home or commercial project, Sherwin Williams and Benjamin Moore are two of the most prominent names in the industry. Both brands have a long-standing reputation for producing premium paints and coatings that cater to a variety of needs and preferences.

With numerous options available in their product lines, choosing between Sherwin Williams and Benjamin Moore can be a daunting task for homeowners and professionals alike.

Sherwin Williams is known for its extensive range of paint products and innovative technologies. With a focus on durability and ease of application, Sherwin Williams paints are often favored for both residential and commercial applications. The company’s commitment to quality and sustainability has earned it a loyal customer base and a reputation for reliability.

Benjamin Moore, on the other hand, is celebrated for its rich color palettes and premium formulations. The brand’s paints are renowned for their exceptional coverage, long-lasting finish, and superior color accuracy. Benjamin Moore’s dedication to craftsmanship and its wide array of options make it a popular choice for those seeking a high-end painting experience.

Key Points

Both Sherwin Williams & Benjamin Moore provide high-quality paints, with subtle differences in product lines that are typically only noticeable to professionals.
The primary difference between the two brands is their ownership: Benjamin Moore stores are locally owned, whereas Sherwin-Williams stores are corporate-owned.
The decision between Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams often depends on personal preference, the specifics of the project, and whether the homeowner values supporting local businesses.

In the paint industry, Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams are top brands, each with dedicated customers. Deciding which is best for your home in Novi, Michigan, is important for the durability and appearance of your interior or exterior paint. Both brands are known for their quality, but they have different strengths.

This post is here to help Michigan residents decide between Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams paint. Which one is best for your home? Keep reading to find out!

Sherwin-Williams vs. Benjamin Moore: Which Paint Brand Is Best?

The answer is that either brand could be the best choice for you!

Both Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams paints perform well. While there may be minor differences between their products, only a professional painter is likely to notice. Benjamin Moore stores are locally owned, whereas Sherwin-Williams stores are owned by the corporation. If you prefer to support local businesses, you might choose Benjamin Moore paint.

Quality and Durability

It all comes down to quality. If you buy cheap paint, you’ll get a cheap result. Invest in quality paint, and you’ll get a great finish. The real challenge is choosing the right color.

Both Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams are known for their high-quality, durable paints. Both professional painters and DIY enthusiasts trust them. Whether you’re painting indoors or outdoors, these brands offer long-lasting and attractive results.

The Cost Of Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin-Williams Paint

Price & Value

The recent rise in paint prices highlights the value of prioritizing quality over price. Opting for high-quality paints from Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams can be more cost-effective in the long run, needing fewer coats and providing better durability.

Rising Paint Prices

Why Avoid Buying Any Other Paint Brand?

Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams are industry leaders for a reason.

Both brands invest heavily in research and development.
They offer products for every type of project.
Their higher prices reflect their superior quality.
Lower-quality paints require more coats and labor.
They also have shorter lifespans, necessitating more frequent repainting

Benjamin Moore & Sherwin-Williams Store Locations Comparison

Benjamin Moore has approximately 6,640 stores across the United States.
As of 2024, Sherwin-Williams operates 3,925 store locations in America.
Benjamin Moore stores are locally owned, whereas Sherwin-Williams operates on a corporate level.
Due to this difference, Benjamin Moore stores and retailers carrying their paints may offer varying products.
Benjamin Moore’s local ownership can attract those interested in supporting community businesses, while Sherwin-Williams’ national presence provides convenience and uniformity.
Both Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore have stores in Novi, MI.

Color Selection

Benjamin Moore & Sherwin Williams offer a variety of colors, making them both great choices for homeowners.
Both brands provide extensive color options to suit different tastes and preferences.
They offer color consultation services to help homeowners make informed choices.

Color Consultations

Benjamin Moore

Benjamin Moore’s color consultation costs $99 for 30 minutes. You’ll receive guidance from a color expert, a professional rendering of your space, and up to 5 color swatches of your choosing sent by mail. Note that not all Benjamin Moore locations provide this service. Benjamin Moore provides a Virtual Color Consultation through a 30-minute Zoom call. You can choose between two options: It costs $50 for a consultation for one interior room, which includes five color swatch samples. Alternatively, a virtual consultation for the exterior of the home costs $60 and includes eight color swatches.